POLITICAL PLURALISM IN ISLAMIC LEGAL THEORY AND PRACTICE

Authors

  • Marinko Zekić Institut za slavensku filologiju, Sveučilište Adama Mickiewicza u Poznanju

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.58301/BM16451-285z

Keywords:

Islam, religion, pluralism, secularism, political rights

Abstract

The latest developments in the Arab-Islamic world have been marked by a massive wave of unrecorded protests and socio-political changes in recent history, with global implications that are within the framework of the Arab Spring, and have affected the Muslim countries of the Middle East and North Africa. These developments have again actualized the issue of the (in)compatibility of Islam with liberal Western democracy, launching a broad debate on the correct Islamic standpoint on this issue. The Islamic world is well behind the West in the fields of identification, implementation and institutionalization of a democratic political system, despite the declared will of the citizens for their implementation. It is illusory, however, as the Islamic world would be expected to develop state-legal and socio-political systems in Muslim countries as a whole to follow the fundamental principles of liberal democracy, which in the West is the main criterion in determining the character of alternative systems of government, without taking into account the Sharia as one of the sources of legislation and guidelines of socio-political system. Since Islam gives unequivocal dogmatic-legal and moral-usual provisions that regulate all spheres of life of the faithful and the community, Islamic scholars do not agree to the unconditional acceptance of the norms resulting from majority decisions on the legal process if they are in conflict with the fundamental postulates of the Islamic belief, adhering to the only legally valid and binding code of conduct for the Muslim law of God, expressed in the form of the Qur’an and Sunnah. On the other hand, democracy is nowhere to be implemented in the same way, but its character is contextually dependent on a number of historical-cultural and socio-political factors that determine the form of binding national regulation and legislation, as well as the level of political pluralism, fundamental rights and freedoms of citizens, and so the process of democratization in Muslim countries is placed together with the Islamic state and legal tradition, under the laws and principles inherent with the cultural and psychological reality of climate in which it is implemented. Activities that are currently recorded in the Islamic world do not necessarily have to target secularisation of Muslims and the establishment of the Islamic concept of government based on God’s supreme governorship and sovereignty, but rather a specific process of democratization of the Islamic society, that although inspired by the experience of Western democracy is neither Western nor secular, precisely because of the pervasive influence of Islam in the life of Muslims.

Published

2025-01-30

How to Cite

Zekić, M. (2025). POLITICAL PLURALISM IN ISLAMIC LEGAL THEORY AND PRACTICE. BALCANOSLAVICA, 45(1, 2), 85–94. https://doi.org/10.58301/BM16451-285z