POLITIZATION OF ТНЕ ETHNIC IDENTITY OF ТНЕ ТОRВЕЅН ("NASHINCI") PEOPLE

Authors

  • Jelena Svetieva

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.58301/BM0332-3307s

Keywords:

Торбеши, Нашинци, етнички предели, етничка култура, западна и северозападна Македонија, пограничје, македонско-албанска граница, македонско-српска (косовска) граница, исламизација, албанизација, турцизирање, Голо Брдо, Гора, Дебарско, Дебарска Жупа, Долна Река, Горна Река, етничка транзиција, македонски јазик, дримколско-голобрдски говор

Abstract

If one analyzes each census made after the Second World War in Macedonia, one would notice a transition of parts of the groups of Islamized Macedonians to different categories of ethnic origin. An expert in demography could immediately notice the illogical nature of the numbers on the demographic growth and fall—it can be noticed even by an amateur. As a consequence of this "ethnic instability" of the Macedonian Muslims, sometimes in the censuses the number of "Turks" grows, while other times the number of "Albanians" or "Muslims"/"Bosniaks." It seems that some of them feel a resistance towards the descriptive public ethnic name "Islamized Macedonians," which seems to contain a kind of "imperfection" compared to the other public ethnic names. When it comes to the "Nashinci" ("Our people"), science has also made large obstacles in their ethnic identification, since it contains a lot of politics, as much as religion. It is a matter of "theses" that explain their "Turkish," "Bulgarian," "antiq-Greek," "Albanian," and other origins. In this sense, the value of the thesis on their Macedonian origin, based upon Turkish documents, is being reduced; that is, this thesis is "read" as only one of many other theses, although the feeling of ethnic and cultural relation with the Orthodox Macedonians is contained in the general term "Nashinci."

From a scientific point of view, it is without any sense to prove the correctness of the thesis on the Islamization of these people, having in mind the huge number of original Turkish documents that are available to everyone who is interested in this issue. Unfortunately, the number of interested "Nashinci" is still small. Their culture values oral tradition above the written word, so this is how planned and constructed "theses" can pass, since they are presented in the form of folk legends.

Currently, in Macedonia, faith is an important factor in making the decision of publicly announcing belonging to a certain ethnic group. An important number of Islamized Macedonians are about to lose their identity, and they have an identification problem. The constant threat of melting into another nation and culture could finally mobilize all those "Nashinci" who feel ethnically and culturally non-identified or marginalized. In this sense, an exit from the confused and different ethnic designation of a part of the "Nashinci" (Torbeshi) in Macedonia, who are not convinced of the correctness of the term "Islamized Macedonians," could be made by agreement on a different mutual name as a public verbal symbol of their ethnic culture. This could give an impulse to their unification through civic or political forms of organization, in the same way it is done by the "Pomaks" from the Pirin part of Macedonia, in the Republic of Bulgaria ("Sdruzenie na Pomacite za kultura i evro-integracija v Bulgarija"). This would mean an end to the intensive politicization of the ethnic identity of the "Nashinci" that belong to Islam.

Published

2025-01-30

How to Cite

Svetieva Ј. (2025). POLITIZATION OF ТНЕ ETHNIC IDENTITY OF ТНЕ ТОRВЕЅН ("NASHINCI") PEOPLE. BALCANOSLAVICA, 7–23. https://doi.org/10.58301/BM0332-3307s

Issue

Section

Articles